Advertisement

NZ Landlord Loses Trash Battle Against Chinese Embassy

  • Web Desk
  • Share

NZ Landlord Loses Trash Battle Against Chinese Embassy

NZ Landlord Loses Trash Battle Against Chinese Embassy

Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement
  • NZ landlord loses claim against Chinese embassy over rubbish costs
  • Chandler Investments sought NZ$960 for cleaning, rubbish removal, and key cutting
  • Tenancy tribunal rules in favor of Chinese embassy, citing sovereign immunity
Advertisement

In a dispute involving a New Zealand landlord and the Chinese embassy regarding rubbish disposal, the landlord, Chandler Investments Limited, lost its claim seeking NZ$960 ($559; £462) for cleaning, rubbish removal, and key cutting expenses for a Wellington mews house.

The tenancy tribunal ruled against Chandler Investments Limited, citing that the Chinese embassy was protected by sovereign immunity.

Sovereign immunity prevents a government from being sued in another country without its consent.

According to tribunal records, adjudicator Rex Woodhouse determined that the tribunal lacked jurisdiction in this case and consequently dismissed the claim.

While representatives from New Zealand’s Ministry of Foreign Affairs and Trade (MFAT) were present during the tribunal hearing, neither party involved in the claim attended.

Mr. Woodhouse noted in his judgment that he was able to contact a representative from the Chinese embassy, but she had no knowledge of the application.

Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement

The applicant for the tenancy was recorded as “Embassy of the People’s Republic of China”, and compensation was first sought last May at the end of the tenancy.

MFAT noted that there were commercial exceptions to immunity but the adjudicator said he was “not persuaded that the rental of a residential dwelling to an embassy would be commercial in nature”.

“It was definitely a quirk we didn’t see coming,” owner Chris Chandler told local media, adding that he thought the amount would have been “immaterial” for the embassy.

“No more diplomats, and according to our property manager, that’s the advice he gives to others in the same area as well,” Mr. Chandler said.

Advertisement
Advertisement

New Zealand has witnessed multiple instances where landlords found themselves entangled in tenancy disputes with foreign embassies.

In 2018, a similar situation arose when a claim was filed against the Deputy Chief of Mission for the European Union, Eva Tvarozkova.

The claim amounted to $11,700 (NZ$20,000) in unpaid rent and related expenses for a property in Wellington.

Initially, the tenancy tribunal ruled in favor of the landlord, affirming their entitlement to the money. However, New Zealand’s Ministry of Foreign Affairs and Trade (MFAT) later intervened, citing Ms. Tvarozkova’s diplomatic immunity, which shields her from prosecution.

Consequently, they requested a reevaluation through another hearing.

Also Read

Maharashtra Police Officer Suspended Amidst Online Gaming Win

Indian police officer Somnath Zende suspended after winning 15 million rupees on...

Advertisement

To stay informed about current events, please like our Facebook page https://www.bolnews.com/international/2023/10/nz-landlord-loses-trash-battle-against-chinese-embassy/amp/.
Follow us on Twitter https://www.bolnews.com/international/2023/10/nz-landlord-loses-trash-battle-against-chinese-embassy/amp/ and stay updated with the latest news.
Subscribe to our YouTube channel https://www.bolnews.com/international/2023/10/nz-landlord-loses-trash-battle-against-chinese-embassy/amp/ to watch news from Pakistan and around the world.

Advertisement
Advertisement
Read More News On

Catch all the Business News, Breaking News Event and Latest News Updates on The BOL News


Download The BOL News App to get the Daily News Update & Live News.


Advertisement
End of Story
BOL Stories of the day
Russia flaunts nuclear and conventional power in massive drills
Netanyahu admits Israel faces "Isolation"
Pakistan demands removal of referee following controversy in India match
Geneva to host UNHRC debate today on Israel’s recent military offensive against Qatar
Doha Summit: Qatar accuses Israel of undermining peace, committing war crimes
19 wedding guests die as bus plunges into river in Zamfara
Next Article
Exit mobile version